4th Place · TSA Nationals

Drag to rotate · scroll or pinch to zoom · click a panel to inspect
Engineering DesignBioretentionEnvironmental SciencePrototypingTSA

The AzotoColumn is a bioretention system we built for TSA's Engineering Design event, where the theme that year was "Managing the Nitrogen Cycle." Excess nitrogen from fertilizer runoff drives eutrophication and dead zones in nearby waterways, so our team designed a filtration column along the field border (soil, sand, and gravel layered around nitrogen-fixing plants like clover) that a farm's runoff flows into by gravity, before a pump sends the cleaned water back out for irrigation. We named it after "Azoto," Greek for nitrogen.

We picked the bioretention design after scoring it against two other concepts (an AI-driven soil-sensor network, and selective catalytic reduction for vehicle exhaust) on cost, effectiveness, and maintenance. Then we spent most of the season iterating on a physical prototype: testing water flow and nitrogen levels, chasing down leaks, and tuning the soil layering until the numbers held up.

Nitrogen-rich fertilizer runoff is a major cause of eutrophication. It feeds algal blooms in nearby lakes and rivers that die off, use up the dissolved oxygen, and leave "dead zones" where aquatic life can't survive. The same runoff can leach into groundwater and drinking supplies at levels linked to health risks like blue baby syndrome. Farms need a way to keep using nitrogen fertilizer without losing most of it to runoff.

  • Had to be buildable and testable as a physical scale prototype within a school year, not just a paper design.
  • Had to hold water without leaking, or the flow-rate and nitrogen-level tests would be wrong.
  • Had to stay affordable and installable on real farmland without disrupting how the farm already runs.
  • Had to work across different soil types, rainfall levels, and farm layouts instead of one specific site.

Choosing bioretention over an AI sensor network or catalytic reduction

We scored our three candidate solutions (a bioretention filtration area, an AI-driven soil/moisture sensor network, and selective catalytic reduction for vehicle exhaust) in a Pugh chart on cost, effectiveness, accessibility, maintenance, and water resistance. Bioretention came out on top at +2, over the sensor network at 0 and catalytic reduction at -2.

Reason:
The sensor network and catalytic reduction both needed expensive, specialized hardware and ongoing maintenance. Bioretention uses passive, cheap materials (soil, sand, gravel, plants) that farmers can maintain themselves once it's installed.

Tradeoff:
Bioretention takes more physical space and more upfront digging and layering than a sensor-based system would, which makes it a harder fit for very small farms.

Switching to a pre-built container after chasing a 446 mL leak

Our first water reservoir was hand-cut plastic sheets sealed with hot glue and duct tape. During testing it lost 446 mL of water we couldn't account for. We tested the mesh filter and the tubing separately in controlled side-tests, ruled both out, and confirmed the leak was coming from uneven, hand-cut seams in the container itself. Switching to a pre-built, slightly curved storage container cut the leak to 50 mL, and a custom 3D-printed seal around the pump intake got rid of it completely.

Reason:
Every mL that leaked threw off our flow-rate and nitrogen-level data, so until the reservoir was watertight we couldn't trust any of our test results.

Tradeoff:
A pre-built container can't be shaped to the prototype's exact interior the way a hand-built one can, and that caused its own fitting and stability problems we had to solve separately.

Concentrating perlite in the top third of the soil layer

Nitrogen testing showed elevated nitrate in the filtered water, which meant the soil wasn't holding onto nitrogen well, so we tried adding perlite (a lightweight, porous volcanic glass) at different soil depths. Putting it only in the top third of the layer improved ammonium infiltration into the soil, while a perlite-free bottom layer kept porosity low down there and limited how much nitrogen could leach through into the collected water.

Reason:
We tested several placements instead of assuming more perlite is better, and the answer depended on depth: perlite near the top helped infiltration, and keeping it out of the bottom stopped it from opening up leaching paths lower down.

Tradeoff:
This layering is harder to build consistently than a uniform soil mix, and it only works if the soil composition is right in the first place.

  • Filtration dropped nitrate from 25 ppm to 5 ppm and ammonium from 15 ppm to 3 ppm across our water samples, and pH stayed stable through the process.
  • Cut prototype volume by 75% and reservoir leakage from 446 mL to effectively zero after redesigning the water container and pump seal.
  • Estimated a full one-acre installation (excavation, lining, filtration media, pump, sensors, grading) at roughly $17,600. That's expensive upfront, but it gets offset over time by lower fertilizer and irrigation costs.
  • Placed 4th at the WTSA State Conference and went on to present the project at TSA Nationals.

  • The AI sensor network was the flashiest idea we had, and it scored a 0 on the Pugh chart. Soil, sand, gravel, and clover scored +2, mostly because farmers can maintain them themselves.
  • Our worst problem was a 446 mL leak from hand-cut plastic seams, which we hadn't thought of as a risk at all until the data stopped adding up. No diagram would have shown us that.
  • Where the perlite went (top third only, not mixed throughout) mattered about as much as using perlite at all.